Offtackle

Football news for every down

The Notebook: Pittsburgh Is Building Toward Something Specific. The League Is Watching to Find Out What.

McCarthy's roster additions say everything about the offense he wants to run. The quarterback question is still open. And Indiana just signed a stadium bill that changed the conversation in Springfield.

Week two of free agency opened Monday without the quarterback question in Pittsburgh being answered, and I want to spend this morning talking about why that unanswered question is the most interesting story in the league right now.

Here is what Pittsburgh has done in the first week and a half of the new league year: they traded for Michael Pittman Jr. from Indianapolis and signed him to a three-year, $59 million contract. They signed Rico Dowdle, who rushed for 1,076 yards in Carolina last season, as their primary back. They re-signed Cameron Heyward on a two-year extension. They brought in Jamel Dean from Tampa Bay for the secondary. Pittman, notably, played under Mike McCarthy in Dallas.

That is a very specific group of players. Pittman is a big, physical receiver who operates at the second and third levels of the defense. He is not a burner. He does not need to create separation with speed. He wins on timing routes — curls, comebacks, crossers — when the quarterback has the anticipation to deliver before the receiver is fully open. Dowdle is a downhill runner who ran behind Carolina's offensive line and picked up yards after contact on outside zone concepts. He is not a change-of-pace back. He is a feature back in a system that wants to run the ball and use play-action.

McCarthy is building an offense that requires a specific kind of quarterback. I have been making calls for a week. What I hear around the league is this: the specific quarterback this roster is being constructed for has not yet said yes or no.

Aaron Rodgers has not announced anything. Pittsburgh has publicly said very little. But the way front office people are reading these additions — Pittman's intermediate-route profile, Dowdle's physicality, the run-game infrastructure — is consistent. This is a ball-control, timing-based, trust-the-intermediate offense. It is being built for an experienced pocket passer who processes quickly and does not need explosive-play opportunities to function. That is not a young developmental quarterback. That is a very specific description.

The decision is coming. It may be the biggest remaining story of this offseason.


A few other things I'm thinking about this Monday morning.

The Chicago stadium situation got materially more complicated over the weekend, and I want to say clearly what happened.

Indiana did something real. The state senate voted 45-4 to establish the Northwest Indiana Stadium Authority in Hammond — a formal legal mechanism providing public funding for a potential stadium across the state line. Governor Mike Braun signed it into law within an hour of the vote. That is not a statement bill. That is a signed law that creates a real alternative pathway.

The Illinois House, meanwhile, adjourned Thursday without holding a floor vote on HB 910, the property tax incentive bill that forms the core of the Arlington Heights proposal. The House returns Wednesday, March 18.

What that organization is navigating right now is a genuine two-state scenario. The legislators returning to Springfield on Wednesday will know that Indiana has already acted. How that knowledge affects the political calculus in Illinois is genuinely uncertain — it could be an accelerant, or it could be irrelevant depending on the dynamics inside that building. Someone I spoke with who is familiar with the negotiations said the Illinois option is still viable but that Indiana being real changes the conversation in ways that are hard to predict from the outside.

The vote that happens in Springfield this week — or doesn't happen — will tell us whether this story is ending or extending into its fourth year.


The Trey Hendrickson deal in Baltimore is four years and $112 million, and I want to say something about what that number tells you about Jesse Minter.

Minter spent the past two years as a defensive coordinator in the AFC, studying edge rushers from the opposing sideline. He came into his first offseason as a head coach and identified the best available pass rusher on the market and signed him. He did not test secondary options. He did not use Hendrickson as leverage for another conversation. He moved.

New head coaches sometimes feel pressure to make a visible splash with a skill position player — something the fan base recognizes immediately. Minter went straight to the defensive front. He went to the position he knows best, in the conference he spent two years studying. That is a statement about organizational philosophy, not just roster construction.

Baltimore has historically built its defensive identity around its front four. Minter's first major transaction says he intends to continue that tradition with the player he wanted most.


The situation in Minnesota with Kevin O'Connell and Kyler Murray is something I have been thinking about since the signing was announced, and I want to be direct about what it is and what it isn't.

Murray signed a one-year deal with the Vikings after Arizona released him. The contract structure is notable: Arizona still owes Murray $36.8 million, which means Minnesota's actual cap outlay is minimal. The deal also prohibits the Vikings from using the franchise or transition tag on Murray next offseason — he will be a free agent regardless of what happens this season. J.J. McCarthy is the designated franchise quarterback. He is not going anywhere.

What O'Connell has done is acquire a legitimate option — not a journeyman backup, not a placeholder, but a player who was a Pro Bowl-level quarterback when healthy — in a room that now has genuine competition and genuine clarity of stakes. O'Connell managed the Darnold/McCarthy situation last year with enough directness that both players understood their standing. He will need to do the same thing again. The difference is that Murray represents real upside. If he plays, and plays well, conversations get complicated in a way they did not get complicated last year.

CBS Sports graded the signing A+. I understand why. The organizational risk is in the management, not the acquisition.


One more thing before I close.

Las Vegas has a plan, and they have said it plainly. Klint Kubiak is expected to use the Raiders' first-round pick on Fernando Mendoza — the first quarterback selected in the first round by that organization since 2007. Kubiak was asked about Mendoza during the combine and offered a short answer that has been cited across the evaluation community: you want a winner.

I like the organizational clarity of that. Not complicated. Not hedged. Teams that know what they want and pursue it directly tend to build faster than teams that manage the options. The Raiders have had two regimes of managed options. This one appears to be making a different bet.

Whether Mendoza is what the bet requires is a question April will start to answer.


I got a note after Saturday's column from a reader in Louisiana who told me Travis Etienne grew up ninety miles from New Orleans. I knew that, and I had written around it twice this past week without saying it plainly. He signed with the Saints on Friday. He went home. Sometimes this game reminds you what it's actually for.

Offtackle Staff Writers

← Back to today's edition